Couple holding hands in the dawn of new possibility
|

Trust, Leadership, and the Affair the World Is Watching

I’m writing to you while news outlets across every platform, whether finance, technology or global affairs, are screaming front-page headlines about a truly astonishing, and potentially the most expensive, affair in human history. I think a lot of that is hyperbole, but it certainly is quite a dramatic thing that we’re watching unfold. And if you’re like me, this is all feeling quite close to home.

I coach emerging and established leaders and executives in navigating complicated workplace interpersonal dynamics, visibility challenges, and personal performance goals and aspirations. My professional clients are working in an environment where trust is so critically important, but where it is often not well established or is uncertain. We transact with trust in many different ways and in many parts of our lives.

I specialize in coaching two seemingly distant domains: career and relationships. The reason I coach professionals in both their professional progression and their relationships and marriages is that there are underlying themes that tend to echo each other in both spheres. They are, in fact, very related, and the concept of trust is the glue that holds together a functioning, healthy marriage as well as a fulfilling career ascent. When my professional clients start to see progress on their visibility and progression goals, they start to ask how these powerful perspective shifts might be applied to their marriage.

The essential ingredient

I co-host a podcast with the amazing Sara Liddle, a fellow relationship coach, and we have been recording for six and a half years. Our podcast is called Relationships with Geordie Lass & Doc Sass, and we have a fantastic library, which I’ll link here. In episode 109 we tackled the issue of trust, and Sara shared a survey showing that the one ingredient you need for your relationship to be truly happy, to thrive and to be successful is trust. We need to feel safe, and we need to connect with our partners with pure trust, knowing that we can rely on our partner and that they’ve got our back.

Without trust, we are stuck in a catabolic, hypervigilant state where we’re always looking over our shoulder and experiencing some element of elevated cortisol or stress. Trust is the element that helps us be truly relaxed in our relationship, so we’re not burning excess cycles worrying about things that may or may not be happening. As we said on our podcast, when we’ve got a lot of trust in a relationship, we can deal with ambiguous information and with not having all the details, because we trust that our partner has got it covered.

The fear this sensational infidelity story ignites

Many people have been reading about the emerging events of this very famous and expensive infidelity situation, and it feels like every day a new shocking detail emerges. I think many of us are wondering what it would be like to be the spouse of this person, whose intimate affair details are rolling out to an incredulous global audience. I think it terrifies many of us. For those of us who already struggle with secure attachment in our relationships, this truly is the worst-case scenario. Having multiple affairs discovered in the public gaze is the kind of humiliating event that many of us with anxious attachment and rejection fears have spent our whole lives trying to avoid. This kind of drama makes us say: See, this is why I have always been checking his phone. This is why I never trust men. This is why I don’t feel safe in a relationship.

So, I think it’s important to put what we’re seeing in this news cycle into perspective, and to get back into the driver’s seat in terms of trust.

Trust is something we choose

The scary thing about trust is that it is not something that is given to us. It’s something that we choose to take. I choose to trust the person in my relationship, or I choose not to trust them. There’s nothing anybody can do to ensure that they are 100% trustworthy.

A healthy relationship has interdependence rather than codependence. A healthy relationship is one where everybody has their own private devices and phones, their own sets of friends and hobbies, their own workplace and professional pursuits, their own private thoughts. In a healthy relationship, we should spend considerable time experiencing life together, but we must also spend a fair amount of time apart, cultivating our own individual hobbies, passions and pursuits. Where those Venn circles don’t overlap, we are left to our own devices, and truly every human being has free rein over what they do with their free time. So, it is impossible to have an adult intimate relationship in which we know what our partner is doing, saying, communicating or thinking at every given time. Trust must be present within ourselves because our partner’s behavior cannot be fully known or controlled. Have you seen those cringy Instagram and TikTok videos about the hair-raising lengths people go to in order to investigate suspected infidelity, which involve breaking into phones and stalking their partners? This is the extreme end of what happens when one tries to secure 100% proof of trustworthiness – it is a futile pursuit.

And because we so rarely have complete information, we always have a choice of interpretation. We can either assume the worst of our partner, or we can reach for the most generous explanation.

Usually, we’re not able to bring our boss to therapy.

You can’t bring your manager to therapy

Trust, of course, comes up in the professional domain as well. Many of my clients describe feeling anxious and stuck because there is a lack of transparency in their relationships with their managers. This often plays out through passive-aggressive communication: for example, managers cancel 1:1 meetings for no stated reason, they don’t respond to emails, or perhaps there’s a sense that other people on the team are talking about something that you’re not brought into. These inconsistent signals from their leadership erode trust, and an overwhelming insecurity sets in, which brings about a feeling of powerlessness.

Usually, we’re not able to bring our boss to therapy. While that sounds kind of funny, it’s an interesting thought. In the professional sphere, when I talk about trust-building with my clients, it is almost 100% on my client to decide whether they are going to trust their boss and their leadership, to what extent, and with what. In that kind of relationship there is generally no mediating force that brings the boss and the direct report into the same room to establish communication and trust in the same deep and dedicated way that a relationship coach or therapist might work with an intimate couple.

Thus, the leaders and executives I coach have to make the choice to create a positive interpretation of their leadership’s actions and behaviors, one that meets a bar of confidence that helps them do their best work. For example, if their leader is being very dismissive and distant, a power move is for my client to decide to trust that their boss is really busy and distracted with their own stuff, and that it has nothing to do with my client’s performance or their boss’s assessment of it. When my clients decide to trust that everything is fine (unless informed otherwise) and to avoid interpreting negativity in the signals they are picking up, they are freed up. They get into the driver’s seat and can perform confidently without second-guessing themselves. That often goes a long way to solving the awkward dynamic of silence and apprehension that can develop between a passive-aggressive leader and a confident, high-performing direct report. So, in the professional setting, I find the onus is often on the client to act as if trust were established, and that turns into confident, proactive, transparent action that works in their favor.

Why trust at home is so much harder

In the intimate relationships of our personal lives and in our marriages, establishing trust is a very different thing. As Esther Perel says, the heaviest strain on our marriages and intimate relationships is the set of expectations that no one human being can fulfill. Due to modern cultural influences, we have evolved to expect our partner to be our everything: We depend on our partners to be our 50:50 co-pilots in parenting, in taking care of elderly parents, in handling finances together, and in setting up our home, our professional lives, our way of living and our expenses. We rely on them to be our emotional support. We rely on them to be our social partners, to insulate us from boredom, and to take care of us when we get sick. Then there’s the whole big bucket of intimacy, where we expect our partner to fulfill us sexually, to be on the same page with intimacy, and to want the same type and frequency of intimacy, because in many marriage structures, monogamy is the unspoken rule.

In short, marriages hold an impossible pressure load. In a long-term relationship that might span 50 or 60 years, we as people change, we as a couple change, and we go through so much dynamic shifting that it is an absolute miracle we might end up in the same place together at all. So many different forces push against our boats that it is only natural for them to end up very far apart from each other in the ocean. It’s so hard to tie ourselves to each other, because we’re ultimately individuals who cannot be governed. We are two people who choose to be in a committed relationship with each other, but we can’t control the other if we’re to be in a healthy, interdependent relationship. So many external and internal factors over the years will push us away and apart from each other, and introduce scenarios where we stand to break these often-unspoken rules. Sexual fidelity is one of the biggest rules that we just assume, but it is so tremendously difficult to maintain.

What do I trust you for?

Esther Perel’s book The State of Affairs points to the layers of trust. Trust isn’t binary, where I either trust you or I don’t trust you. It’s a matter of: What do I trust you for?

As we talked about on our podcast, trust isn’t just about whether somebody is going to cheat or not. It’s about whether I can trust this person to completely have my back. If my world falls apart tomorrow, can I trust my partner to pick up the pieces and support me? If I suddenly lost my job, could I trust my partner to help me financially until I get back on my feet? You might have always been financially trustworthy, so I maintain that trust in you, but I might still be working my way back to trusting you to comfort me when I’m sad. There’s trust for so many different things.

The two parts of the trust game

A lot of people are reading about this current infidelity exposé and are perhaps terrified about their own relationships. It is so hard not to overanalyze our partner’s moves: the text message that pings on your partner’s phone at 11:30 at night that they turn over and ignore, or the day they say they’re going to the gym but come back in their business attire, and you wonder what’s going on. Establishing and maintaining trust in an intimate relationship or a marriage is extremely important, but it’s also extremely difficult. Human beings are very unpredictable. We don’t always stick to our word or our routines, and things fluctuate. If we don’t have trust, it’s very easy to over-interpret our spouse’s behaviors in a suspicious manner. Once trust has eroded, we start to see these inconsistencies everywhere and imagine the worst. That creates hypervigilance and a constant state of stress, as well as an antagonistic atmosphere in the relationship, where one person is constantly vigilant over the other. It creates suspicion, and a real sense of resentment and exhaustion in the couple.

There are two parts to the game of trust. One is to act trustworthy: keep your conduct clean in a way that does not arouse suspicion, and be very transparent with your partner. Having said that, your partner will never know exactly everything you’re doing, feeling and acting on, and you’re going to have a lot of interface with the world where your partner is not present. You’re going to have many friendships that don’t involve your partner, and many activities that your partner is not involved in. There are, in my opinion, some black-and-white instances where we must conduct ourselves beyond reproach: Cutting off contact with ex-partners (unless co-parenting is involved) is arguably essential, because the grey areas can absolutely devastate trust. And if there is resistance to this, I ask: What’s the point? What’s the value of keeping a relationship with an ex if it’s just going to erode the trust in your current relationship? Is it more important to avoid conflict with an ex, or is this current relationship more important? The choice is ours, and it is a choice of one or the other.

Trust is a state of being that is yours to choose.

So we first clean up our side of the house and eliminate any actions or inactions that make our trustworthiness look questionable. Beyond that, when presented with a healthy relationship where all signals point to secure attachment, and your partner is showing signs of trustworthiness, it is then up to you to decide whether you’re going to trust them. Trust doesn’t solely come from the other person being trustworthy. It ultimately comes down to: Am I going to choose to be in a state of trusting that my partner has my back, that they have the best intentions for me, and that I am safe in my relationship? As Sara said on our podcast, “Trust is a verb.” Whether we choose to trust somebody, given the information we have in hand, is up to us.

An affair does not have to be the end

Our hearts all break for the spouse of this very famous person. They break because it’s quite likely that this person had full trust in their partner, and that their world view is now shattered. One of the fears of the insecurely attached is: What if my partner has this huge affair and I’m left embarrassed and humiliated? Will I regret that I trusted them?

One of my central beliefs is that a couple can come back from an infidelity event. I see in my practice what Esther Perel has written about: many infidelity events are more of a turning point for a couple, an offering for them to start a whole new relationship on a whole new footing, so long as there isn’t repeated deception and manipulation present. An affair does not have to be the end of the relationship. In fact, it can be the start of a new, beautiful relationship for those couples who choose to embark on that.

We don’t know the inner workings of what’s happening in what is probably the most famous affair playing out before the world’s eyes right now. But I hope that the family and the couple are spending time together to see if they can rebuild and repair, and possibly come out of this stronger than ever before.

Trust yourself first

You can decide to trust, and if for whatever reason your partner breaks trust in whatever way – financial trust, sexual trust or emotional trust – the important thing is to know that you will be able to handle it and deal with it in the worst-case scenario. Like anything in life, you can spend so many cycles being hypervigilant about the worst-case scenario. In a tiny fraction of cases, that hypervigilance and anxiety will prove you right. But the vast majority of the time, you will be proven wrong, and a life lived in an anxious and hypervigilant state is a life unlived.

Trust is a state of being that is yours to choose, not as a gift for somebody else, but as a gift for yourself. Living in trust, living in a relaxed state, forgoing hypervigilance, and enjoying all the gifts a trusting relationship can bring in terms of increased connection with your spouse is worth far more than living in fear, anxiety, hypervigilance and suspicion just to catch the slim chance of a partner doing untrustworthy things.

The goal is to first trust yourself. Trust that you will be able to handle whatever is thrown your way. Trust that a relationship in which you invest your full, open heart is a more enriching, beautiful relationship. And believe in yourself: if that trust were ever broken, you will know what to do, and you will have the skills to come out the other side intact and whole.

Want to hear more? Listen to episode 109 on Trust or browse the full Relationships with Geordie Lass & Doc Sass library.

Similar Posts